| Women in Agriculture |
Tape #505 - Limited Resources and Minority Women
Can we get started, and we'll see if more people come in or if we just
have a nice discussion among all of us.
Since we're a small group, we're going to start out by introducing the
panelists, then what we'd like to do is go real quick along and just briefly
introduce the people introduce the people in the room, so we all know who we're
talking to and we'll do some quick presentations and then, we want to talk and
answer questions and hear your experiences.
My name is Lorette Pachano. I'm
the Executive Director of the Rural Coalition.
And we're a coalition of about 100 minority and limited resource farm
organizations in the United States and Mexico.
We have farm worker groups, we have African American farm groups, we
have Hispanic organizations of farmers, we have Asian farm groups, we have
groups in the Midwest, we have EuroAmerican groups as well and poor communities
and we work with groups like National Family Farm Coalition and others on
agriculture policy, we've worked on trade issues and have been here in
Washington for quite awhile and we've been working over the last couple of
years with the Department of Agriculture on work that they finally started to
do on civil rights at the USDA and the Small Farms Commission. And we had 6 members of our organizations
are men and we got onto the Small Farms Commission including the only farm
worker representative and we do a lot of activities in Washington and have a
great group of colleagues all around the country working on these issues and
what we've notice is you need to be addressing barriers as well as building
possibilities at every step of the way.
So that's what we're going to talk about today and we'll get some local
stories and so forth. And then, let me
briefly introduce Carolyn Prince and Georgia Good, then we'll go around and
introduce everybody and then we'll start out with their presentations, as
well. Carolyn, I didn't get a lot of
background, so you can add a lot, but, and I've just met Carolyn this meeting,
but she's the relatively new director of North Carolina Farm and Rural
Families. It's an organization that's
been around for awhile, but Carolyn's been there, what, somewhat more than a
year, a year and a half and has been doing some excellent work on marketing and
technical assistance for small farmers in North Carolina and she'll tell you
more about then when we get started.
And she and Georgia and sitting her sharing all their family connections
in North Carolina. Georgia Good is the
Executive Director of the Rural Advancement Fund which has been working for
over 50 years in the Carolinas on black farm issues was really the first of the
major black farm organizations and Georgia has been working in this work for a
long time and she's also worked in forming community health clinics, and I'm
proud to say she's the secretary of the Rural Coalition, our organization,
she's on our Board of Directors, and then we have a newly forming organization
called the National Counsel of Community Based Organizations in Agriculture set
up just to work with the Department of Agriculture to represent the interests
of limited resource and minority farmers.
And Georgia is the co-chair of that organization with Greg Smitman of
Intertravel Agriculture Counsel. We
also work with Indian farmers throughout the country. So, you've got some real wonderful people. And then, why don't we just pass this mike
around and have you all introduce yourselves, 'cause we want to know who you
are and, you know, what connections we might find.
Hello, I'm Katherine Steidam, and I work for the San Francisco
Sheriff's Department. I run a
horticulture and training program for prisoners and former prisoners and we
grow foods that we give to soup kitchen and also sell to restaurants. We also plant San Francisco street trees.
I'm Debra Livingston. I also
work with the rural Coalition and this fine panel of esteemed women in
agriculture.
Good morning, my name is Mary Peabody.
I'm the Director of the Women's Agricultural Network and we do education
and technical assistance for women interested in starting and expanding
profitable agrelated businesses and farms and I'm hear basically to build
connections outside because I'm located in the Northeast part of the United
States where we're not very well connected.
I'm Delaura Shed, and I'm from Canada, from the Province of Ontario and
I'm with the National Farmers Union so I work with women's groups.
Good morning, I'm Roberta Williams, from Antigo, West Indies. I am the Director of the Gilbert
Agricultural and Rural Development Center, which is a church-based organization
and we help youths set up agricultures enterprises in our country.
Hi, my name is Elana Claig, and I'm from Jackson, Mississippi, and I'm
just here as a friend of one of the other presenters at another conference.
I'm Diane Rogers. I'm with the
press from Canada, the province is Suschatuan.
Elizabeth from South Africa.
I'm working with Agricultural Women in Farming there.
I'm from Washington, D.C. I'm
Dr. Karen James, I work for the U.S. Department of Agriculture Animal and Plant
Health Inspection Service Veterinary Services and I'm here to learn.
I'm Denarga Hollis and I'm with AIKA and know the experience the other
countries because I need to learn their activities.
I'm Delarga Harris from Columbia.
(Spoken in Spanish)
I'm Joey Bran from Australia.
I'm just interested in coming to see what was happening at one of these
meetings.
Hello, I'm Janelle Pain, I'm a graduate student at Ohio State
University and I'm interning with the USDFAS this summer foreign AG service in
the International Cooperation Development division and we're doing a lot of
work in Africa this summer and I'd like to learn more about recruiting minority
women on my campus that are already AG students maybe into the mainstream
agricultural organizations that are already established and how we can work
together.
Good morning, my name is Moselle Trotter, I'm with the USDA with Office
Communications.
Good morning, I'm Dramelle Worthin with Florida NM University,
Tallahassee, Florida, which is one of the 1890 land grant institutions.
Hi, I'm Kim Berry, I'm with the USDA Natural Resources Conservation
Service and I'm ashamed that I don't know Carolyn or Georgia because I'm
located in North Carolina.
Good morning. My name is Rosa
Cherif. I'm from Mississippi, as a
farmer. We raise pasture poultry and
St. Croix sheep and vegetables, but the vegetables are kind of dry right now,
we're in a drought for the past two months.
But also, I'm with the Marian County Self-Help Organization that we're
dealing with healthy food for families and future concerns of housing and
employment and so forth.
My name is Judith Mocmood and I'm just gonna say ditto for everything
she just said.
I'm Ellen Nolman. I work at the
National Agricultural Library which is the largest agricultural library in the
world and I wanted to make sure that you all knew about it and also to find out
what kind of services we could provide.
Hi. My name is Carol Moss and
I'm the National Project Director for Easter Seals for the Agribility Project
which is a program in this country for farmers and ranchers and farm workers
and their families who have disabilities, which is a minority group as well, so
I'm here to see, to share what I can share and hear what I can hear.
My name's Michele Mosley. I'm
with the State Government in the State of Tasmania, Australia.
Her name is Dorga Has and she's from Columbia and her husband works
with AIKA. (SPOKEN IN SPANISH) She said the reason she's here besides that
her husband works for AIKA and she's very interested in these topics, is
because she worked many years with the development of the community as she was
studying, and now that she lives in Washington, she's a member of 3 different
organizations like BARCO and The Roundtable for Panamercian Women, which deals
a lot with raising funds for scholarship for young women who are interested in
these sort of topics, so that's why she's here. She said she also travels a lot because she's interested in
supporting these programs and also that AIKA supports the Rural Women's Support
Group.
If you have your simultaneous translation, turn it to channel 2 to get
the translation of the Spanish to English.
In the Rural Coalition, we have a lot of members in Mexico and we have
our own simultaneous equipment, and it's muy importante (very important) that
we can communicate with each other.
Ok, I'd like to move forward and we'll start off with Georgia Good in
the panel. We didn't introduce
everybody in the back of the room but maybe we can do that. We're going to talk for a few minutes and
then we'll open it up for dialogue.
Good morning, can you hear me?
I am Georgia Good. And I want to
tell you just a little bit how I got started in working with limited resource
persons because I was low income myself.
I left Buffalo, New York with two children, 25 cent in my pocket and two
suitcases on my arm and came back to Orangeburg, South Carolina where I had
gone to college. I was hired by a team
out of Washington, D.C. called the Transister Corporation; they were looking at
5 different sections of the United States as relates to health care and I was
hired in rural Orangeburg, South Carolina for that purpose. We had a higher mortality rate, we had
unskilled workers, it's an agriculture county, so we found so many things that
was wrong in the whole health care arena.
At that time, we were still going in the back doors of the doctor's
office. We were in segregated hospital
rooms and so I started organizing the people.
When Transcentury left, I didn't have any resources. A man here in Washington, D.C. hired me as a
consultant for $2,500 to put together a
program. I got $25,000 from the Federal
Government who was old HEW, to do a program and after that, I was able to get a
$300,000 grant to do a family health center for the county and that $2,500 have
now grown into 9 million. Now we're not
talking about all the physicians that have come to that facility and have
located their business within the city.
We're talking about millions more and it can be done. But we need resources, we need money in
order to do programs. I now work mainly
on legislation with the rep, we work with coops, we work with struggling
people, save the coop from foreclosure.
We're now doing some greenhouses with those people. We have the young people during the holiday
season selling pointsettas, they call all their friends and neighbors. People that never bought a pointsetta buys
them. And this is called economic development,
but it's on a limited scale. Ladies and
gentlemen, we need money. You know,
during the depression, my family talked about being able to do, they were
sharecroppers at that time, talked about how they would put a few seeds in the
ground, they could always go to the woods and cut some wood, and they could
scrap up a little money for kerosene to have lighting. You can't do it anymore. We don't have much land left. I'm from Union, South Carolina. There was a time when we could just go from
plant to plant. Now we don't have the
skills. They bring the factories in but
people from other places come to do the jobs.
So we do service, so we're underpaid for service; cleaning the rooms,
cleaning the yards, doing the whole bit.
And people have all these million dollars they don't seem to understand
that how much it takes to carry them or whatever their wants and needs, but
they think that you can make $4.50 an hour, pay your rent, keep you lights on
and feed your kids and do it. You know,
we need to re-enter that conversation on welfare reform because that's going to
be a part of the new evolving poverty.
At some point, people used to could say, we can go. We can to the welfare department and get
some food. We could go to the welfare
department and they help me pay my rent.
But I have women on the doorsteps are now saying, "you know, I want
to reserve my little 2 months, my little 4 months, my little year, just for
serious hard time. So we got to be
about the business of we that have are gonna have to get serious. We got to get our sororities, and
fraternities and we got to move from religion to Christianity. You know, there's a difference. You know, we could go across this country
and we talk about Christian, we're a Christian, you got to get removed from
being religious to being some serious Christians. Now, my country has now bounced backed into one of the highest
infant mortality rate again and we have a family health center sitting
there. I don't work that closely with
it, but that's just an example. With
the care, we got to be able to communicate to our young ladies mainly, to come
to the doctor to save our babies and the cutdown on the neonatal rates, you
know, these little babies that cost millions just to save? We got to be able to do that. We go t to empower people and all of the
rural areas. And we do that by
organizing. We got to be unselfish, we
got be honest with these people. They
know when you're honest and when you're not.
Now, the reason why a lot of drugs are in our community, that's a
supplemental income to many families.
We don't understand it, there's a large amount of mamas out there, they
know their sons and daughters are selling drugs and they don't like it, but
that's a supplement to their income. WE
need revolving loans, lady - minigrants, to set up different projects. You know, women can take a dollar bill and
send it 100 ways, but it doesn't take a lot for us. We have to go and revisit that affirmative action and equal
employment hiring practices. We still
need to go to our legislators. Get to
know them. So when they come to Washington,
the man talk about, you got to make them see your face when they come to
Washington making decision. We know
there's a dollar that follows many of these people, but your face also have to
follow these people. You know, when
Senator Hollers talked about health car and health needs, I have been
there. He knows me. Because he talked about hunger, he talked
about health care. Years ago. So you got to make them sensitive. Since we are the prime caretakers of our
children, and because of low wages and high childcare costs, we definitely got
to do some things for working women.
The answer is economic development activities that produces jobs, better
jobs, decreases crime for children, less drug abuse, less child abuse, and
better self esteem. Rural women and
less aggressive than urban women, so we have to help them keep their self
esteem and keep the faith. Often time,
it just takes a little bit of us, who a little bolder than others, to encourage
them on, but we got to get up off of it and really make those motions to help
keep food on the table. The whole
mental health issue. We have a lot of
people that sleeping in the street. We
got to deal with that, you know, for some odd reason, we are embarrassed by
mental health in this country and any of us can get to be mentally ill. I take care of a lady that's a friend of
mine that I met in Orangeburg who was a teacher, who taught me many things, but
she now has Alzheimer. You know, when
you don't know yourself and you don't know your best friend, and you don't know
your children. You know, she never
thought that would happen to her. So we
got to talk about health care, mental health are, migrants and seasonal farm
workers. You know, farm workers, they
gather the food for us. It used to be,
when I was on a group that gathered information for President Carter. The east coast was covered by black males
migrants. The middle and the west was
by families mainly south of the border.
But now, it's mainly people from south of the border and we got to make
it perfectly clear that these people have a life too and that they need to be
treated in a most positive way. So I'm
going to stop now and let the next panelist and then we can discuss some things
further. Thank you.
Ok, Carolyn's going to come up and talk but I wanted to tell you I'm
going to pass around a sign-up sheet.
We've got some materials here, but not probably enough for everybody in
the audits, but we'll send you more information, so make sure you put your
complete addresses and e-mail. And then
also, I'm going to present one set of materials to the agricultural library and
I really hope that, you know, there's stories here of what all these groups of
people have been doing and what we've been doing on civil rights and we hope that
you'll keep it in the library. So, come
on up, Karen.
Thank you and good morning. My
name is Carolyn Prince. I'm the
Director of the North Carolina Coalition of Farming Rural Families. This is our the year, we're a non-profit
agency and the core of our mission is to promote the south economic advancement
of farmers and rural families. I've
been on board since February of '97 and it's been an awesome task and I love
every minute of it. To give you a bit
about my background, I come from a long line of farmers, businessmen and
educators. And I'd like to think that
I've blended all of that into my current job.
I've always wanted to be involved in work that helped people to help
themselves. And what better way to do
it than to help people who are still tilling the land. It means a lot to be able to feed
yourself. And one of my favorite little
comments is to remember a farmer when you sit down to eat, because without the
farmers then, we would truly be in serious trouble. Our agency provides mainly marketing and technical assistance and
we're finding that more of the marketing is needed by small farmers, male or
female, and that we have some women that are the primary farmers on their land,
but in most instances, they're in partnership with their husbands or with their
grandchildren and running the family farm, and they do have a lot of say as to
what is being raised and how it's being marketed. We've been able to expand the traditional marketing channels for
the small farmers in North Carolina, and the past has just been retail sales
maybe roadside stands, u-pick operations, those kinds of things, with the
highway systems coming through that's eliminated a lot of the fine spots fro
roadside stands. You know you can't put
a roadside stand next to the interstate.
And everybody's in a rush to get from one place to the other. There are farmers who rely on contracts with
processors and we all know that when you sell your produce out of the field or
your livestock right out of the pasture, then you receive the smallest amount
of money for your product, for your commodity. And it's very difficult for small farmers individually to be
able to break into the type of vertical integration activities that are
necessary in order to add value to their products and to retain more of that
money. In addition, some other
marketing avenues have been that North Carolina school lunch program started a
program this year and each school district in the state was contacted and told
to buy locally. Ok. The channels were made such that it was
easier for the farmers to deliver directly to the school cafeteria and to be
paid within a short period of time instead of the usual long waiting period for
reimbursement. In some instances, the
farmers have been able to add value, maybe chopping the greens, or slicing the
tomatoes, that sort of thing, to help provide fresh, nutritious products for
the school children. In addition, in
North Carolina, we have a lot of military installations. We've been able to get some farmers to have
their produce being sole in the commissaries.
And it's really rewarding to hear a farmer say, "well, I went back
the next day and everything I had taken the day before was gone, they wanted
all that I had." They promoted it
as being fresh, they promoted it as being grown locally and by small
farmers. They were able to help the
farmers by giving them stickers made up with their logo or their name to help
identify the produce, we put up signs and the actual section, saying, this is
locally grown, this is fresh, and that has been a big help. In addition, we've had some contact from
some processing plants interested from buying from minority farmers. If you are in the southeast, you may have
heard of Glory Foods. They have a
wonderful brand of greens and beans and peas and other types of foods, canned
goods. They have very good shelf space
and identity in the supermarkets. They
will buy from the small farmers. They
have very strict requirements in terms of tolerance for weeds, for defects or
whatever. So our technical assistance
is to help the farmers make sure that they can meet these requirements that's
needed and requested by the processors.
We find that barriers that may exist for some small farmers would be, as
I said, locations for retail outlets, being able to have the volume that's
needed for commercial wholesale contracts with place like grocery stores or
processors, and to meet those needs, we are organizing farmers to form
cooperatives so that they can have the volume and the extended harvest season
that's often required by let's say a major grocery store. They would like to be able to sell sweet
corn throughout the season and we can organize the farmers in different areas
of the state and stagger the planning dates and they're able to extend the
normal harvest season for something like sweet corn to be able to supply it on
demand. These markets can be very
unforgiving, so it's important to us that our farmers really adhere to the
specifications that are required by the processors and the grocery stores,
because once you've tarnished your reputation, it is very difficult to get that
marketing outlet restored. The other
thing that would be a barrier to small farmers would be having he capital to
take advantage of some opportunities.
For example, we had one processor that wanted 300 acres of sweet
potatoes. They came to us in
February. You plant sweet potatoes in
April or May depending on the location.
That wasn't enough time for us to scramble together the capital because
we knew we'd get the money back but we needed the initial outlay for supplies
and plants and so forth. So those are
the kinds of things that we are faced with.
We depend on migrant labor to harvest a lot of the crops. They may come and they're very organized as
they should be, but they have certain requirements before they will even come
to your field. It has to be a certain
size, they have to be assured of a certain amount of income, they want their
money, if not every day, then certainly at the end of the week. So that creates a cash flow problem for
small farmers. Here again, having
cooperatives will help them to eliminate some of these problems. The other area is that of adding value. Anything that small farmers can do to
increased the value of their crop, whether its washing the cucumbers or the
zucchini or the squash, grating and sorting them into certain sizes, packing
them in standards boxes, taking something like sweet corn to a processing place
where you can hydrocele it to remove the field heat, put it on a refrigerated
truck. This adds value and you get
higher prices for the money. Now, our
agency has a packing shed in the southeast part of the state. We wish we had 2 or 3 in different parts of
the state and that's a goal for the future under my administration, but at this
packing shed, we have hydrocooling facilities, we just built a 600 square foot
cold storage room where small volumes of produce can be held until you have a
tractor trailer load, then transport it to a market. We have refrigerated trucks for transporting the produce under
refrigerated conditions. We have a
2,700 square foot greenhouse that we've used as a demonstration. This past winter we had greenhouse tomatoes
that were excellent tomatoes, almost as good as vine white, but certainly 25
times better than what we would get imported that were harvested at the green
stage and then ripened with gas. There
was good local acceptance from some local restaurants for these tomatoes and
also at the Army installation. We
treated this as a demonstration so that we can provide information to other
small farmers that may be interested in a way of extending their income during
what we call the off season, to do a greenhouse crop, whether its tomatoes or
cucumbers, or bedding plants or other types of commodities that can be grown in
the greenhouse. Many of you are aware
of the situation with tobacco. A lot of
small farmers rent allotments, they don't own them. So anything that affects this tobacco program, will have very
serious repercussions for them. We want
to be ready to assist them to investigate some non-traditional crops. In addition to the greenhouse project, we
have a farmer that's working with catfish. She has six ponds. You may have met her, she's here at this
conference. There is also a woman that
is doing goats. Her goat herd was
started with, I think, maybe 2 or 4 breeding stock that she got through another
project a few years ago. She's doing
quite well with that. She's an elderly
woman, but she takes care of the goats.
She has a ready mark with Hispanics in the area and also the other
ethnic groups that appreciate fresh goat meat.
So it's a small enterprises but it supplements her social security
income, so she is able to stay on her family farm. Then we have what we call my okra ladies; two sisters who've
never worked off the family farm. They
live in the old home place and they knit and crochet and they grow okra, about
an acre of okra. If you know anything
about okra in this country, it's a southern delicacy, you either like it or you
don't like it, but it's very expensive in the supermarkets, and usually what
you see is a very poor quality because it has very strict requirements in terms
of handling once you harvest it. So
they were selling that okra for .75 a pound, just to get rid of it and you go
to the supermarket and it's like $3.00, $4.00 a pound. Ok.
So, that enterprises helps them tremendously. And last year, in my home area, okra was not available. We had a cold, wet spring and the farmers
replanted about 3 or 4 times and they finally ran out of seed, there was not
okra to be had. I think I must have
imported about 100 pounds into my home town from different people, from my okra
ladies in North Carolina. But it's
those kinds of enterprises that help rural women to make ends meet. And women have always been the backbone of
the family and have done all of the farmwork.
You may depend on the men to plow the fields or to do the heavy work,
but when it comes down to it, the women have taken care of the fields, they've
harvested the foods, they've dried it, canned it, frozen or whatever, to
provide for their family across the winter.
So it's very important that agencies like the North Carolina Coalition
of Farming Rural Families and other agencies and programs that help rule women
and women farmers to continue in their work because it's very important.
I just wanted to also give you a note in terms of the list of people
who are on the panel and we've changed around.
Dorothy Barker's just come in, Savvy Horn, from Land Lost Prevention
Project had to go back to North Carolina for a family matter and so Dorothy who
works with us and she's been on another panel agreed to come and sit on. Shirley Shirades just came in and, you know,
Shirley's one of our team that we work together with and Shirley, feel free, to
join us in saying anything that you want.
No, we understand, is there any work that you want to say before you go
out?
I really think it's important for us to try to work together and I
can't stress that enough. We just need
to work to make sure we didn't come here just to come here. Let's try to see if we can make this mean
something for us. It's one thing to get
up and say, you know, you want to work in Zimbabwe and I don't have anything
against that. I don't have anything
against going wherever you need to go to try to do some work, but please let's
try to do it at home. Let's just try to
be together.
We have some great leaders in all this work and some great women that
do this. Luzgood Tierras was supposed
to come out with Washington Association of Minority Entrepreneurs has been to
Washington from Seattle, well from Yakama, Washington about 3 times in the last
month, she came out here to be on the risk management review panels to look at
education grants and she was just unable to get herself out and make another
trip because she had to take care of her organization at home and she sent her
regrets and I want to make sure I cover a little of what she was saying, and
then Dorothy will say a few words and we'll have some discussion.
I want to touch on a couple of points of some of the communities that
are not represented here. We've been
working with the Department of Agriculture for many, many years or sometimes
we've been working against the Department of Agriculture. Right now we're probably doing a little bit
of both and in the last 2 years, some of us met yesterday with the secretary
and talked with him about some of these issues and we've been really trying to
get the Department to recognize that it's not just a case of helping these
poor, small and limited resource farmers that don't know how to do what they're
doing. If you've been a black farmer in
the state of North Carolina or Alabama and you've stayed in business for all
these years, you must be a rocket scientist with everything that was against
you. And one of the things we've been
trying to say is people of color and small farmers have always been generally
apart but the backbone of agriculture in the United States. And we try to tell the Department to reflect
on this and remember they're not only a part of the past but a part of the
future. There's a poster we've been
talking about that was put out by Economic Research Service on the history of
agriculture. And you look at that
poster and what it says about African Americans, the first thing it says, it
says, "slaves came into the United States first in 1619 and they displaced
indentured servants". How
rude. That's the kind of perspective of
what does this mean? The way that
history is presented. This country,
it's economic basis was cotton, tobacco and the trade in human beings. That was the labor. Where did the land come from? Does the basis of U.S. Agriculture was from
the indigenous people and there's nothing on that chart; there's one little
reference to the indigenous people of the United States, but not only that,
they were the first agricultural researchers on this continent. And the indigenous people of the North
America have developed the crops that now provide 52% of our food supply. And the way our research service is
structure at the Department of Agriculture, it goes through the states, and
Indian people are told you have federal dollars that pay for extension services
but you can't be a part of them because you're a separate nation and you don't
pay taxes to the state and they have to pay for extension services on Indian
reservations. And they haven't been
able to do it. There were no soil maps
for Indian reservations. Right now the
disaster definitions in U.S. programs say that you have to a certain amount of
acreage of land to qualify for disaster payments. And so what they'll do is they'll say, "well, there's all
this land but the Indian disaster is separate from that and that reservation is
too small to qualify, so even thought there's the qualifying number of acres,
they cut out the Indian reservation and people there don't get the drought
assistance. You know, these are some of
the kinds of things that we're encountering.
On our role coalition brochure, there's a letter we got from
agricultural workers. We work with the
agricultural workers and it was two workers in New Mexico who wrote to us,
"we were working in the fields. As
usual, the owner did not have the bottle of water for us that was part of the
law. So we had to drink from the
ditch. We know this water has many
pesticides, but there was nothing else.
We drank it. The next day we
were sick. Because we missed a day of
work, we were fired." And this is
in the chili fields in New Mexico. Our
chairperson runs an agricultural worker center built by the farm workers in El
Paso and we're working with Rutgers University and what we're studying is we're
having the workers come in every day and tell us what fields they worked in,
what crops they were working on and we'll be able to know what pesticides they
were exposed to. But they're also asked
questions, "Did anybody provide water in the fields today? Were there field sanitation facilities to
wash your hands, to use toilet facilities?
And what we're finding is, approximately 80% of the workers don't have
those facilities that are required by law.
And, the issue of disability for farm workers is a very important
one. One of the things that we want to
be doing it preventing those disabilities.
Carolyn mentioned the issue of negotiating between small farmers and
farm workers. And that's a very
important issue. One of the things that
happens is you're not dealing with the farm workers, you're dealing with the
labor contractor, and the labor contractor is somebody that generally exploits
the people that they work with. We have
some of our farm worker organizational members working to set up cooperative of
farm workers to negotiate directly with farmers so that you'll have a contract
and be able to work out payment plans.
All these problems, if we put our minds to it, are something that can be
solved. You know, if we're interested
in food safety, we want to work together, we even tried to get a grant from the
Department of Agriculture to do a demonstration grant to show how to educate
farm workers and the most sustainable methods.
But in the most modern sustainable methods to work with farmers so that
there's a professional crew of farm workers that can come. You know, and would it be best if one worker
built all of GM's cars. It doesn't make
sense, we want to be employed in agriculture, we want it to be something that
returns money to our communities. You
know, one farmer and 4 ½ million farm workers would make it a more correct
analysis. And then the other thing is
that, you know, the African American farms were a backbone and it was a major
place where it was from the farms that came the middle class. That's where the civil rights movement came
from, was from the land. And you know
you can fight an affirmative action over some jobs that somebody else owned,
but the basis of people being on the land and having the independence of
ownership is important for more reasons even than just feeding those families
and feeding all of us. So that's why
we've been so committed to doing this work.
We've tried to work strategically with all of these communities together
to get them to work together to really fight at the Department of
Agriculture. In 1997, the Department
issued a landmark report called The Civil Rights Action Team Report, Civil
Rights in the U.S. Department of Agriculture and it laid out a lot of plans we
just went through yesterday with the Department. A review of what they've been doing on their work and there's a
long way to go, but there are more people moving there. One accomplishment that we have is one of
our member organizations, we got their leader to apply and he's now the Associate
General Counsel for Civil Rights at USDA and he brought his team of new
attorneys and they actually sat there and were on a number of cases before we
had to tell them to do it, you know, to really deal with what needs to be done. There's a migrant worker situation where
we're buying out the farmers on like a popka but doing nothing fro the
workers that are displaced. So it's
trying to reverse the trend and go in and say there are solutions. Ye, and you can write and ask the Department
of Agriculture. Ask the Department of
Agriculture people here. Out of that
report also grew the National Small Farms Commission and we had 6 members
including the only farm worker member and, you know, when we get 6 out of 30 on
any team, we're going to do a good job. You know, I think if we can get at least that much
representation. We had Mung farmers,
Indian farmers and farm workers and there is a section on farm workers, there's
a lot on marketing and the Department is trying to implement that report and
we're hoping that something good really happens out of it. We've also been working with communities in
Mexico and throughout the United States and we're trying to create an arok
coalition, something that we call the Supermarket, and it will be an electronic
network where we bundle and sell products among all of our communities. We have, you know, small coffee producers in
Mexico, we have the women make dried humiakas, dried hybiscus flowers and make
a very delicious tea. There's sesame
seeds. There's folks that are doing
dairy up in the northeast. We have
apple producers. We have somebody that
would love for us to set up a juice manufacturing plant, and even with what we
have in our communities, when you blend the seasons that we have from the
northeastern United States out to the west coast down to Mexico, then
Bricketton, Mississippi's been looking all over Mexico for where can we find
okra that's available for sale at Christmas time. We have one of the coops down in Mexico is going to be harvesting
80 tons of Chili a day for 3 months and want to sell that. It extends the season in Mississippi by 9
weeks and you can get a better contract for selling those products. That's the kind of thing, but we're looking
for just the investment which we haven't been able to find to get a
computerized network and one or two marketing people to work with, all the
marketing people. And we put the
proposals in to USDA and the AKITA missions review them and they say,
"small farmers don't use computers and they don't have the skills to do
this work." Well, part of the
thing is the determination that needs to happen and so that's what we've been
trying to address strategically. We've
been working on legislation. All that
is in our world coalition report, the history of the work that all of these
groups have been doing for 20 or 30 years and we're making some progress. We're also doing and we've done over the
last couple of years an outreach training at USDA. We've been working with USDA to set up a small farms office that
works with small and minority farmers.
All of them together that deals with the civil rights issues. For people outside the United States,
discrimination, exclusion is still a very big problem in the United States, its
in the counties, its not only in the department, it's just the way society
still is. And so we've been trying to
deal with that. At the outreach
training, we're trying to get the outreach office set up to strategically teach
the department how to reach our numbers.
Lou Guituirrez has gotten 300 new hispanic farmers in one county on the
land. Now that's not the
statistics. The Mung farmers in
California have 1,200 new farmers. We
want to see more new African American farmers on the land. We want to see more of this small
Euroamerican farmers all over, and it can happen, it can happen on Indian
reservations. Agriculture can resurge;
it just requires investment. We've
created a voter registration form for the USDA County Committee election so
they could find new farmers. You know,
we have counties where there are 50 more percent minority farmers and they're
not represented on the county committees that make all of the critical
decisions, and this has been a big issue.
So its changing the structure at every level, but we have to work here,
it's like with a crowbar at the national level, and the secretary's listening,
but it's a big establishment we need to change. And, you know, our treasurer was here in town yesterday, John
Zippert, from the Federation of Southern Coops. He works with Shirley.
And just the kind of stuff you're dealing with, right now it's a court
case they've taken, it's two counties very resistant to change. Four black churches were burned in those two
counties in 1995 and the federal bureau of investigation used that as an
opportunity not to find out who burned the churches, but to investigate the use
of absentee ballots by African Americans.
The older African Americans don't like to go and vote at the poles
because they've been treated badly, so they get an absentee ballot and mail it
in, and they found 14 questionable ballots.
7 questionable ballots out of 1,400 and they now have 2 people in
jail. This is a county that had 75% of
the black farmers voted in the county committee elections and still got no
black farmer elected. These kinds of
situations we're still dealing with and that's one of the reasons why it's very
hard for black farmers to be able to do what they need to do and we have to
keep on working on those issues so then we can get to doing all the kinds of
ideas that Carolyn is talking about.
Once we remove the barriers, we really believe that the small and
limited resource in minority farmers are part of the future and we're gonna see
more of them, and we're going to keep on working until that happens, and
they're gonna bring us a safe food supply.
So, that's what I'd like to say and I'd like to turn it over to Dorothy
for a minute and then we're gonna open up the questions.
Good morning, I'm Dorothy Barker from Outswit, North Carolina and I am
the Director of a non-profit organization.
We started with Reverend Ziti Harris of Durham, North Carolina and Dr.
Benjamin Chaves. And the mission then
was to keep North Carolina's two remaining black dairy farmers on their land as
owners and operators. So we had to come
up ways with creative financing to do that.
And after we done that, we made connections with other groups, the help
of Project International, helped us when we had a disease in our herd that
killed over 50% of it. It helped us
during a time when there was a drought in the mid 80s. The Mennonites and Ralph Page, the
Federation, I had met Shirley Sharad, but we hadn't met the Executive
Director. Then making linkages with
other organizations helped this other farmer who, we thought that we were
limited resource but he had lost an arm due to a farm accident and they were
living in a small house so the habitat built them a home to help them and they
helped them with resources. It was a
community effort, where they could not get money, he couldn't money from the
federal government. I think he was
borrowing from another agency. So,
these are the kinds of things that we started in 1987 and our organization has
grown today with funding starting in '95 and we were working with the Kellogg
Foundation, a very small organization.
But what I had to do was to go out and to find the needs of the minority
and limited resource farmers in a 7 county area and after I did that, we tried
to find self help initiatives that would help them to get back into or stay on
their farm as owners and operators. And
some of the problems that we ran into, there were a lot of barriers and the
women who were trying to take ownership of their land through by if their
husband had passed, brother or some male figure in the family had passed, they
could not acquire this land. It was two
cases now with the new civil rights, well, it's not new, but since 1997, working
in the east, it is 2 women that they have lost their brother and the Farm
Service Agency will not sell them their land.
They're putting it up for foreclosure.
I have another lady farmer who had her inheritance was an old farm house
and about 25 acres, but before her and her husband could obtain money from Farm
Service Agency, no then, it was Old Farmers Home Administration, she had to
give up her heritage, she had to give up her house. Either sell it, or turn it over to another family member which
she did, and they told them to purchase another house, so they got a mobile
home and after they did all of the paperwork that was required by the agency,
then they would not loan them the money for them to go into their
operation. So what I did during the, when
they started having the meetings with Secretary Glickerman and bought out all
of the discriminatory practices with USDA, I connected her with the firm,
hoping the she could get good representation because she did not have the
monies for a lawyer and their case was a part of the class action. As a result of these practices, our Farm
Service Agency, OFMHA, a lot of families have been dislocated, dismantled. I have seen big, viable men reduced down to
about 175-150 pounds, maybe that is the size that they should have been, but
this is the size that they were not, they were big, viable pillars of their
community and they are reduced down to people dragging oxygen tank, they're
walking with walkers, they're in wheelchairs, and they are someone want to give
them a plaque and honor them for the service that they have done. Why not have given them monies to help with
their organization, not give it to them, but give them an opportunity to even
at least apply for these services. I
have seen people, and as well as myself, go into Farmers Home Administration
and apply for a tract or apply for a loan and they will tell you that there is
no money in this program. And just
finding out last year that you are supposed to be able to put in an application
whether there is funds or not, and then you are to be notified when those funds
come in, this does not happen. And even
if you go in on the 29th, they will tell you on the 1st of September there is
no money in this fund. So these are
some of the barriers that we are facing and these things need to be stopped. I don't believe that these things are
happening in the 90s and some of the people said that when they came out to the
sale of our family land in November of 1997, that we don't believe that this is
happening here in Outswert, North Carolina, but it happens. Some of the other things that the farmers
have run into as women is that they will tell them, I had a lady that wants to
start a business and her husband had borrowed money from Farmers Home
Administration and they told her, well, we have loaned your husband money and
our assets will not be covered. We
cannot loan you money, and besides, whose going to help you do this work, this
is no work for a woman, you can't do this.
And I was told myself that you'd better not start another entity. We loaned you money for dairy cows and that
is all that you're supposed to do with any proceeds that come from this money
is to go back into the business. Some
of the other things that I've done was to help farmers to get certified
organic, hopefully that they could get a better price for their product. That was hard, because most of the farms
have been just ate up with chemicals because this traditional tobacco
allotment. But we have to make that
transition from tobacco because we don't own allotment, we don't own the
poundage. The majority of us rent
poundage. The poundage that we have
from our farm, we did a demonstration last year growing organic tobacco and did
a comparison of the monies that you get with organic tobacco to get with
commercial, and the Santa Fe Tobacco Company located after talking to us
several leaders, they located in Oxford.
And we had 4 farmers to sign up, but only just 2 of us
participated. But this year we had
another farmer added. And we did a
comparison as to the prices that you get.
We had a capacity for about 13 acres of tobacco. And they told us in a consent order that we
could keep the tobacco poundage to help pay for the house and the 20 acres that
they let us keep and at the day of the auction, the tobacco poundage was the first
thing that they sold. So these are some
promises and things, and this happened all through the federal court. So if you do not have the support of, you
just wonder, how can do these things when there are rules and they make new
rules every day to fit their criteria.
If they have a rule and it seems as if you're going to benefit from that
law or that rule, they will make a new rule.
One of the programs that I did start was Black Women in Today's
Agriculture and from that North Carolina ANT University has taken up that
program and has started. And they told
me that black women in today's agriculture was... I didn't mean to say that...
I could either go to minority women in today's agriculture or just have women
in today's agriculture. So, I took that
name off and retried, we came up with some self help projects. And one of the things that we did we grew
peppers, we grew flowers, we grew alufa and tried to market that. And we got markets for the luff. I had youth programs, Youth in Today's Agriculture,
and we did tomatoes. Steak tomatoes is
one of our biggest cash crops. And from
those tomatoes, the first participant was able to do a down payment, made about
$5,000 after expenses. And how we did
that, we could not afford the boxes.
And that is what Pearl was talking about, was coop building and that is
good if you can coop and I thank her because she afforded me the opportunity to
go to Eps, Alabama to be trained in coop business. And that is one of the things that we need,
we needed those programs and when I came to Washington in '97, I discovered
that they did have a fund for that. But
they have these funds, they have these programs set and they're in Washington,
D.C. How do we get them down to the
local level? I know that you have to
get your county commissioners, your county director for Farm Service Agency,
letters from the University, you have to get support letters. But, you know, I'm told, if you can get the
support from your county Farm Service Agency official, that will help you in
getting your proposals in getting monies down for your state. But they tell us all these good and
wonderful program and they're on paper and they're in Washington, but we do not
qualify for them when we apply for them.
It's very hard. So as a group of
women and a very strong group of women, I hope that we can ban together and try
to asset some of these funds that are there.
I had one lady that wanted to, what we did as a result of the AFS
Kellogg Foundation, we had some demonstration money in because what I tried to
do was to tell them that we could not run to all of the state facilities to
bring farmers there. It was hard to get
them there to see a demonstration. So I
fought for them to put demonstrations on the farmer's farm that they may reap
an economic gain after the demonstration is over because the college mentality
was, if you can't do a demonstration of a farmer's farm, he's just going to
plow it up. But if you put that
demonstration on that farmer's farm and he can get his neighbor to come over
and take a look at it. And he will do
that. If you can get a lead farmer in
the community and they will be that mentor for the next farmer, you can do some
successful projects, because we have done some. But the thrust of it was to make sure that after they did this
demonstration and the colleges had documented their lessons learned, that the
farmer could sell their product and help put money in their farm where they
could not borrow money. And what we
tried to, we did a demonstration to let you know that farming can be 12
months. And so we did these
demonstrations, and farming can be done on 12 months, and if you plan on laying
crop, you would have money to start your operating money for the spring. So, I'm gonna end now for time, but this is
just some of the things that are happening in North Carolina and something
about our non-profit organization Operation Spring Plan.
There is lots and lots of stories that we can tell and I imagine there
are some out here. If, in order to be in
the official proceedings, you have to use the microphone if you ask a question
or if you have a comment. You know, I
think you heard a lot of stories so I guess, Debra, you help do that.
(TEXT SPOKEN IN
SPANISH)
And I believe I heard most of the question, we were getting another
headset up here. One of the things,
it's very important in what you say in terms of getting the documentation for
central American workers, both in working in Mexico but also in the United
States and protecting the workers' rights, and it's an issue that we're really
concerned about. The Mexican government
is right now waged a lawsuit against Decostar Egg Farms in the state of Maine
for their exploitation of Mexican workers, and so we think the efforts to
protect workers' rights is very important.
They produce 11 million eggs a week and they use largely Hispanic and
Central American and Mexican migrant workers and they have a very high
workplace injury rate, but they will not report things like broken legs on the
mine. They won't diagnose workers that
way. So, I guess that, and their living
in trailers in the state of Maine that have limited heating or air conditioning
in the summertime and we're trying to work on compliance. We've been working with a few U.S.
departments finally to try and address these issues and we've also been having
some conversations with the government of Mexico about training and pesticide
safety and so forth. So I don't have a
particular answer just to your question except to say, it's a very important
issue and it's one that we have to deal with, you know, with all the countries
that are in the migrant stream. Is that
a help? I hope that that's enough of an
answer, that's about as much as I can give you, but I'd like to talk with you
more later and thank you for the work you're doing.
I'm from Ontario. And we're
rich with history of people, the slaves crossing up, the going up and so forth
and two things I want to mention. One
day the farmers simply dropped their tractors and what and had a meeting. And they formed an organization called the
National Unity. They decided they
weren't going to have any more prejudice in Canada and everybody was going to
be treated alike. T make a long story
short, they worked several years and succeeded in getting the passing of the
government for our civil rights and human rights. But when you read about it, you think the Canadian government did
this, isn't it so nice. But it was the
colored farmers of the Dresden area.
And if you're familiar with Dresden, you know Harry Beaches Stone wrote
the book "Uncle Tom" and this is where the man, Tom, resided and
farmed and because he couldn't get loans and help, he went to England and the
Queen granted money and land to the people there. So if you go north of Nolan Sound, you'll find that the people
there are agricudhariadis, they're not half-breeds, and the land was
given to them by the Queen. But if you
come from Michigan up, there were slaves who have their freedom and I just want
of mention my husband's great aunt.
There's no slavery in the Shad history, and Maryann was on a
farm, she taught school, she believed everybody should have an education. She got paid in grain and food and what not
because nobody had any money. She's had
no one to fight for her rights, so Mary crossed back over at the age of 60,
obtained her law degree, and when she came back, they would not accept her
because she was a colored farm woman.
Back she went, she got a higher degree, and when she came back, they
were forced to accept her in Canada.
She won her cases and they refer to Mary as the black beauty with the
sharp tongue. And all of this has come
about because of people on a farm, farmers at the grass roots, fought for
this. One thins we feel that these
people of color, not rewrite the history book s for the Board of Education, but
put us between the pages where we deserve, and let the work know exactly our
contribution to Canada, and again, it's farm people, that have done this.
More questions? Or comments?
Maybe we can just get people in this write just to write to the
Department of Agriculture on some of these issues that you've heard this
morning would be helpful. You know,
little by little, we can chip away at the system. Two things that I missed.
We're training women in North Carolina for higher construction and the
building trade. We do it all. Volunteer, we have a Vista project for food
distribution, cleaning of food to give to needy people and but the main point
is, I think we need to be in touch with people that comes to Washington and in
your local community there makes a decision for all the people. Be in touch with them. I can't say that enough..
I would take just a minute to share with those of you in the room
something about the project that I work on.
I think it's importance at this conference that we share some solutions,
as well as raising the issues and the questions which, of course, is important,
as well. But this program that I'm a
part of, is one that actually does have funding through USDA. It was money that was allocated by the
Congress of the U.S., and its specifically to work for, with farmers and
ranchers and farm workers, who have disabilities. And one of the things that we're trying to do is to inform people
within this country that folks, that people who have disabilities can continue
to work on the farm. That when they go
in to get a farm loan, just as any person that's a minority person in this
country, people look at them at say, "well, you're coming in here in a
wheelchair, how do you expect to get on a tractor? Forget it, you're a bad risk.
We aren't going to give you any money." So none of the things we're trying to do through this program is
to educate people out in the agriculture communities and commodities, people in
banks, people who are rehabilitation counselors, people who are vocational
rehabilitation counselors, that folks who have disabilities on the farm, who I
should also say parenthetically, often don't call themselves disabled, but they
come in and say, "Well, I don't have a hand, but that doesn't mean I'm
disabled." In any case, that these
folks can continue to work and can continue to work successfully. So, this program is established, it's called
Agribility and it's established to help spread the work that people with
disabilities who are often small farmers in this country, can continue to
work. And then, we also provide
assistance to them by sending a staff personnel to their farm to help assess
what it is that they want to do and how they can modify their equipment or
their home or their tools or their operation in order to accommodate their
disability so that they can continue to do the work that they have chosen and
that they love. So it's a program that
is run with very little money in the scheme of things. There are 18 states in this country that
have an Agribility project and it's run with $85,000 per state. It's very low, we keep trying to get additional
funds. And, just to let you know that
this program and that we have resources that are available. There's an 800 phone number within this
country. There's a website. So, I want you to know that it's around and
if you're interest in it, let me know and I'll give you my number or my
card. The 800 number goes to the extension
services at Perdue University, which is the extension service site partner for
this program. I'm from Easter Seals,
we're the non-profit disability side of the partnership. So the number at Breaking New Ground is
(800) 825-4264. And my number here in
Washington is not 800 but it's (202) 347-3066.
I also have an e-mail address, if you have e-mail, you can send to me
and it's Carol_maus@nessdc.org. And as
I said, I'm at Easter Seals.
Thank you for letting me give you this information. Thank you for your work. Are there more questions? We're just about real close to the end here,
so...
Well, just to cover several things.
One, about the farmers market.
We have a very successful program in Pennsylvania and it was started
years ago, when I worked with Dr. Leon Sullivan, who many of you know, who
worked in the industrial aspect of getting people, minorities, into the
mainstream. And what we did, was we, in
Philadelphia and Pittsburgh and other metropolitan areas, and our state
agricultures lands in Harrisburg, we set up farmers markets. And, in many cases, they've been supported
by church groups or volunteer groups and from early spring until the snow
falls, these people go in, the farmers from the areas go in, and they set up,
tailgate markets and they sell to the cities.
And they've been extremely successful and they've broadened their scope
from just vegetables and fruits to handicrafts and so forth. And they usually are scheduled and very well
promoted by the Department of Agriculture and they have a schedule of at least
two days a week, wherever they might be.
And that's our alternative to not being able to have the roadside
markets because of the interstates.
And, the other thing I'd like to comment on is we hear a lot about
looking to USDA and to looking to national governments for assistance. But, I'm wondering, and I'm curious because
there's so many people here from North Carolina. So I want to ask a very blunt question. And that is, how supportive are your state officials as far as
minority programs and helping to solve the financial and social issues at their
level?
Yesterday at a meeting on direct marketing, the South Carolina
Department of Agriculture Director said that black farmers weren't really
interested in farming and weren't interest in farmers markets. So, that's one start.
Well, clearly, that person from South Carolina was grossly
uninformed. I live in South Carolina, I
work in North Carolina, I claim both states.
And I buy a lot of produce from a black farmer at a farmers market, a
state farmers market in Florence, South Carolina. Anyway, in North Carolina, our Commission of Agriculture has an
assistant that runs a small farmer program.
The agency that I represent is funded by appropriations by the General
Assembly. And, I would say that North
Carolina is one of the few states that does devote monies towards helping
small, minority and part-time farmers.
But it's still a struggle, because a lot a people think that, well, who
are you and who do you serve, and why can't they go to the Agriculture
Extension Service for help, that sort of thing. And, it's a constant battle to educate the people in Raleigh,
state capital, that there are the people who are least likely to seek help or
to receive help from the Agriculture Extension Service, because they go after
the more visible, the high profile types of individuals and we'd like to think
that we compliment what they do because often times, we will get assistance or
ask for assistant from a local extension person. We may not always get it, but we do seek it to help the audience
that we target on programs like our agency and Ms. Barker's agency. There's always going to be an underclass of
people when you operate in a capitalist society. So there will always be a need for organizations like ours and
work that's being done be people in the audience. Does that answer your question?
I would suggest that if you need someone to contact in North Carolina,
Raleigh, one I've been a many, many years friend of, your big Jim Graham. But, the Vice Chairman of your Human
Relations Commission is my daughter-in-law.
Talk to Peggy Alexander, and I'm certainly going to talk to her about
your problems. And we talk a lot about
the problems of minorities in North Carolina.
And I think you'll find a voice and assistance in Peggy.
Just a quick comment that ties in to the question that you just
asked. I'm from the state of
Florida. I work at an 1890 institution
and in terms of addressing extension needs, we at the 1890 institution have
great difficulty in securing funds via the state legislature to address
minority, African-American, farm issues and in terms of our extension
personnel, so it's a hard roe to hoe.
I would just like to say, the Special Assistance, the Minority Special
Assistance to Commissioner Graham, had a title and he didn't have money for a
program and we came together as a group and met. And, he was given a small amount, not the amount that he asked
for, to go in and to promote, small family farmers. I think we did this a couple of years ago. And last year, '97, our organization
received $1,000 to promote small family farm through signs, roadside signs, or
either flyers, brochures to promote that.
This year, he has appropriated a little money, he went in and asked for
more money because our thing was, you are given this title, a desk, a computer
and a chair to run a program, you're not given any dollars. So with our efforts and constantly talking
to him, he was a little bit adamant about going and asking for the amount of
money once we done that budget to say, this is what North Carolina needs. And so, he was funded more than what he
actually asked for. So this is just to
let you know some of the programs that we face here in North Carolina.
Right, in terms of working with the 1890s, institutions are doing, they
exist on federal dollars, and if they get any state money, it's through the
graciousness of the state, but usually they don't. So it makes it difficult, but we've always been resourceful
people and we're always going to succeed.
I think there's a couple more comments, I want to observe time, though,
and we're really through with time, if that's ok. I wanted to show you, this is the sequel to the original
Department o Agriculture Civil Rights Report.
And there's also a National Farm Small Commission Report. And Mocille has been our friend in office
communications. If you're interested in
either of these reports, please write to Mocille or give her your name and
address before you leave this room. The
other thing I'd like to say is we all need to keep on working together and no
matter where you're from, either in the United States or in Canada or
outside. We'd love to be in touch on
the chapter of African American History in Canada. You're welcome to join the Rural Coalition to be a part of our
network. Also, with our national
counsel of CBO's and agriculture, and just let us know and write to us because
we'd really like to be working with you.
I'd like to thank all of our panelists for their excellent, excellent
work that they've been doing for many years and all of you who are doing
excellent work at the same time, at to take Shirley Sherard's words,
"Let's keep on working together".
Thanks very, very much.